AN ARAB DOCTOR AND AN ULTRA-ORTHODOX JEW FIND COMMON GROUND IN A COVID WARD
Nurses wearing protective gear are seen inside an isolation ward for covid-19 patients, at the Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital in Jerusalem. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
By Steve Hendrix
April 25, 2020
JERUSALEM — When Jesse Michael Kramer was hospitalized with the coronavirus, he realized as soon as the doctor in the spacesuit introduced himself that it would be a rare encounter.
Kramer is an Israeli ultra-Orthodox Jew; Fadi Kharouf is a Palestinian Muslim.
“Fadi, it’s an Arab name,” Kramer, 75, said as he recalled his time at Jerusalem’s Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital, once he was back home convalescing in the ultra-Orthodox neighborhood he seldom leaves. “He was very good to me.”
Such unlikely meetings have become more commonplace after the pandemic struck with particular fury in Jerusalem’s most insular and religious Jewish enclaves, just a few miles — but cultural light-years — from the Arab neighborhoods where Kharouf and other Palestinian physicians and nurses live.
The pandemic has created a bridge between their worlds. Hundreds of Jewish covid-19 patients are being treated by Arab practitioners they might never meet outside the hospital. Sick Palestinians are getting care from Jewish medical staff they might otherwise avoid.
For many health-care workers, exhausting themselves shift after shift, this shared fight against a common enemy has provided a boost of mutual esteem amid the dark days of crisis.
Doctors Fadi Kharouf, center, and Matan Fischer laugh during their shift at Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
“I am sure we may have extremely different political views, but they are very respectful to me,” said Kharouf of his Jewish patients, who are mostly from ultra-Orthodox groups, known here as Haredim.
For his part, Kharouf, 30, has learned much about Judaism’s strictest sects. He has helped covid-weakened men wrap the leather straps of the ritual prayer tefillin around their arms. He has learned many of their dietary laws.
Preparing to enter one of the hospital’s three covid wards on a recent afternoon, he paused while zipping up his tear-proof hazmat suit to recall a few Hebrew words of the Mourner’s Kaddish prayer, which he has heard recited at many bedside deaths, sometimes by family members he has helped patch in via cellphone video.
“I am proud of my Palestinian culture,” he said. “I have many things to criticize about what is happening in the outside world. But in here, we are all just humans.”
‘We are healers’
Doctor Limor Rubin, second from right, and nurses put on protective gear as they prepare to enter an isolation ward for coronavirus patients at the hospital. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
Israeli hospitals were already known as one of the country’s few cultural crossroads, a place where everyone from Jewish settlers to Palestinian activists comes to receive nationalized health care, and to deliver it. Israel’s Arab minority, which makes up 20 percent of the population, is well represented in the ranks of those wearing scrubs and lab coats. Many speak of medicine as a good avenue into an economy they feel otherwise shuts them out.
As the epidemic has exploded, the sense of caring for the other has heightened. Advocates have seized on the adulation being showered on health-care workers to argue for greater civil rights for the Arab doctors and nurses among them.
Shir Nosatzki, a Jewish human rights activist, recounted a day in March when Israelis went to their balconies at 6 p.m. to applaud health-care workers, then, later that evening, the news reported that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had labeled Arab Israeli members of parliament “terror supporters.”
Nosatzki and her group, Have You Seen the Horizon Lately, quickly produced a video that depicts doctors and nurses dramatically removing their masks to reveal Arab faces and head coverings. It has been viewed almost 2 million times.
“You can’t salute them for saving our lives and at the same time say they are not legitimate participants in our society,” Nosatzki said.
The coronavirus outbreak is the latest emergency that medical staff have had to address across ethnic lines. At times of war and terrorism, assailants and victims often end up in the same emergency room, treated by both Jews and Arabs.
Rubin is seen at the entrance to an isolation ward for covid-19 patients. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
Kharouf puts on protective gear as he prepares to enter an isolation ward to treat coronavirus patients. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
Sigal Sviri, the Jewish physician heading Hadassah’s covid-19 intensive care units and one of Kharouf’s medical mentors, recounted her first shift as an emergency room doctor in the early 1990s. It was full of screaming victims from a bus hijacking that had ended with a crash. Suddenly, she realized she was treating the hijacker, a young Palestinian.
“I was very young and very scared,” she said. “I wasn’t going to refuse but I didn’t know how to react.”
Then she saw the care another surgeon was taking as he stitched up the wounds on the man’s face. She asked why. “ ‘It doesn’t matter what we feel,’ ” she recalled the doctor saying. “ ‘We are not judges. We are not prison guards. We are healers.’ ”
Decades later, Sviri has marveled at the durability of that ethic as coronavirus swept the country.
“No religious Jew has ever told me, ‘I don’t want to be treated by an Arab doctor,’ ” Sviri said. “No Arab patient ever says, ‘I don’t want to be treated by a settler nurse.’ They wake up on different sides of the fence and they meet at Hadassah.”
At the beginning of the outbreak, she knew staffing was going to be tight. Not only did Israeli Arabs volunteer for the quadruple shifts, but so did several of the West Bank Palestinians who were being trained at the hospital. The risk for them, she said, was not just from the virus but from other Palestinians at home who might treat them as pariahs for helping Israelis and for potentially transmitting the infection to the West Bank.
One of those doctors, Haitham Alamlih, said he never hesitated to sign up.
“We are all fighting the same battle,” he said between shifts from his family home in Hebron. “So many Jewish patients are shocked. They say, ‘You are from Hebron and you are treating me nicely? Oh my God!’ ”
Kharouf poses for a portrait at his brother’s house in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Beit Hanina. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
Kharouf, who was born in Israel and is a citizen, said that being a doctor hasn’t immunized him against the indignities that Arabs face in Israel. He said, for example, that he was recently held for four hours at airport security before being allowed on a plane. The security agents, who threw away his gift box of chocolates, never said why he was singled out.
He is planning to marry as soon as the virus restrictions are lifted, but even then he said he won’t be able to invite his West Bank family, most of whom don’t have permits to enter Israel, to the wedding.
When he is on call, he stays at his brother’s home in an East Jerusalem neighborhood and sleeps on a sofa by the living room window, because that’s where the cell signal is strongest in this marginalized part of the city. “I know this street would be paved if it was not in an Arab neighborhood,” he said, pointing down at the rutted dirt lane.
Kharouf, center, talks to colleagues during their shift at Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital. (David Vaaknin for The Washington Post)
Hospital life makes him feel “complete,” he said. He has Haredi patients who call his cellphone to ask questions and check on his well-being. He was one of the Arabs who covered for the Jewish staff during Passover, just as Jews now cover the wards each evening during Ramadan while Arabs end their fast around the breakroom table.
“I do believe that if we at Hadassah were the politicians, we could have peace,” said Naela Hayek, an Israeli Arab nurse, who says she now has enough command of Judaism to become a rabbi. She and Jewish colleague Julie Benbenishty have sought to share some of what they call “health-care diplomacy” through an organization called Nurses in the Middle East.
As to whether the good feelings will endure once the crisis is over, Benbenishty has her doubts. For a research paper, she once surveyed dozens of ultra-Orthodox patients to see whether their experience in the hospital had changed their view of the Arab-Jewish schism once they got out.
The answer was largely no.
“They said the hospital was a very special place where everyone got equal care,” Benbenishty said. “But on the outside, that still wasn’t the case.”